Top 46 of All time

(not a multiple of 5 because
I keep adding & subtracting movies)

1.  Heart and Souls
2.  Forrest Gump
3.  The Shawshank Redemption
4.  Pleasantville
5.  Kramer vs. Kramer
6.  Magnolia
7.  American Beauty
8.  Good Will Hunting
9.  The Truman Show
10.  Shakespeare in Love
11.  Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind
12.  Adaptation
13. Synecdoche, New York 
14.  Fargo
15.  The Paper
16.  Lost in Translation
17.  Children of Men
18.  Birdman or (The Unexpected Virtue of Ignorance)
19.  Donnie Darko
20.  Dark City
21.  Heat
22.  L.A. Confidential
23.  The Usual Suspects
24.  The Thin Red Line
25.  The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring
26.  Titanic
27.  The Abyss
28.  Dancer in the Dark
29.  Dogville
30.  The Diving Bell and the Butterfly
31.  Moonlight
32.  Dunkirk
33.  A Simple Plan
34.  A Time to Kill
35.  Ghost
36.  Dead Poets Society
37.  Her
38.  The Hours
39.  Big Fish
40.  Life is Beautiful
41.  Brokeback Mountain
42.  Braveheart
43.  Anomalisa
44.  The Fall
45.  Arrival
46.  Parasite
 

And almost every day, I think about adding a movie like Jerry Maguire, or Stand By Me, or Requiem for a Dream, or Juno, or even Tootsie.  But I don't.  Though Dead Poets Society was a relatively recent addition (even though I've loved it since I was a kid) - so you never know what may happen.

On any given day, the ordering feels like it wants to be something different - so I just don't think about it or look at this list too often, cuz that would just madden me, as it never feels quite right.  Our personal relationships to movies are ever-ebbing-and-flowing things that depend so much on any day's mood, memories, and unpredictable stimuli.  So more think of this as an unordered list of 46 amazing movies that I personally connect with in beautiful ways.  And I hope you do too.